Tue 9 Jan 2007
And to go along with the top 10 of 2006, here are ten older films I especially enjoyed last year.

1. Woman Ascending the Stairs
It’s hard to believe the Mikio Naruse retrospective at the Film Center was only eleven months ago. And while it didn’t achieve the heights of the Ozu retro from the year before, it did feature this masterpiece. Hideko Takamine, who appeared in many of Naruse’s features, stars as a middle-aged geisha who must find a way to buy a bar of her own or get married to a man she doesn’t really love. Naruse’s best films are melodramatic and deeply affecting without being sentimental, and Takamine gives a towering performance.
2. The New World
Director Terrence Malick returned to theaters with a gorgeous tone poem set around the story of Pocahontas and John Smith, but it’s really a meditation on innocence and loss, nature and civilization. Malick and cinematographer Emmanuel Lubezki (who also shot Children of Men) create images of extraordinary beauty that have lingered in my mind ever since I saw it in January. And the use of Wagner’s “Das Rheingold” is especially transfixing. It might be Malick’s best film, and that’s saying a great, great deal. — full review
3. All that Heaven Allows
I waited to see this Douglas Sirk weepie until I could see it on the big screen, and I’m glad I did. His spectacular widescreen color compositions are amazing to behold, but those would be empty eye-candy without a powerful script about conformity in the ‘50s and excellent lead performances from Jane Wyman and Rock Hudson.
4. Side/Walk/Shuttle
Northwestern’s Block Cinema included this Ernie Gehr experimental film on one of their programs. Shot in a glass elevator on the outside of San Francisco’s Fairmont Hotel, the film repeats a slow trip up and down. But with each variation, Gehr changes our perspective through how the camera is placed, what’s in focus, or how the film is edited. A city film that’s also a reflection on the process of seeing.
5. Hud
Somehow I had missed this quintessential Paul Newman performance until Doc Films showed it, and it’s just as iconic, if not more, than his turns in Cool Hand Luke and Butch Cassidy. Add in stunning widescreen cinematography from James Wong Howe (one of classic Hollywood’s best) and a stark script about a bickering family of ranchers, and you’ve got a masterpiece.
6. Far Side of the Moon
I wasn’t familiar with the work of Robert Lepage until I saw this riveting, wonderfully creative drama. An adaptation of his own play, he also stars as twin brothers coping with their mother’s death. The track record of director-actors isn’t a good one, but Lepage brings together the cerebral and comical for a marvelous mix.
7. Flowers of St. Francis
Pure joy! Roberto Rossellini provides a portrait of St. Francis that makes the monastic life seem exuberant and delightful. Moments of deep spirituality combine with hilariously earthy moments for a religious film that even atheists can enjoy.
8. Best of Norman McLaren
McLaren was a well-known Canadian animator who’s been largely ignored in the States, but this traveling program of his shorts (tied in with the release of a seven-disc dvd set) was a revelation. I could take or leave the live-actor, stop-motion animation, but his traditional animation, often set to jazz music, is simply awesome. And while watching it, I suddenly realized where the inspiration for half of Sesame Street came from.
9. Land of Silence and Darkness
An early Werner Herzog documentary that focuses on a group of people who are both deaf and blind. An older woman named Fini Straubinger emerges as the film’s focus, and her enormous personality is captivating. Herzog brings his customary mystical touch to bear and creates a documentary of stunning beauty and power.
10. Counsellor at Law
I haven’t seen even close to all of William Wyler’s oeuvre, but what I’ve seen (The Best Years of Our Lives, Roman Holiday, Funny Girl) has left me underwhelmed. But that’s not true of this crackerjack law-firm drama. The great John Barrymore plays a lawyer who’s left his working-class roots behind, and Wyler expertly juggles issues of class and politics while creating a thoroughly enjoyable drama about a man walking an ethical tightrope. The script, with its rapid-fire and witty dialogue, shows its theatrical origins, but Wyler uses the office setting (and some glorious high-contrast lighting at the climax) to strong effect.
And since we’re here, how about two more pairs…
Borzage x 2
This year was my first encounter with director Frank Borzage, and now I want to see as much as I can. Especially if they star the spectacular Janet Gaynor. Street Angel and Lucky Star are late silent works, and Gaynor is absolutely luminous in both, while Borzage’s trademark romanticism uses silent cinema tropes to full effect.
Mizoguchi x 2
The Story of the Last Chrysanthemums and The Sisters of the Gion won’t displace Ugetsu or Sansho the Bailiff from my list of favorite Mizoguchis, but it was a thrill to see them on the big screen. Chrysanthemums, in particular, was a reminder of how Mizoguchi, more than any other director, uses space to tell his story. His long diagonal shots and particularly the contrast between foreground and background reveal how flat most other films are.
11 Responses to “The Top 10 Old Movies of 2006”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
January 9th, 2007 at 8:55 am
I’m glad that you caught up with Side/Walk/Shuttle and liked it so much. Definitely one of the best from a great, great filmmaker.
January 9th, 2007 at 10:20 am
Left “underwhelmed” by The Best Years of Our Lives? J. Robert, I don’t know if I’ll ever be able to love you again in the same way.
I don’t if you’ve kept an eye on Long Pauses this year, but I watched twenty or so Wyler films last summer. If you liked Counsellor at Law so much, you’d probably also enjoy Dodsworth, Jezebel, and The Little Foxes.
January 9th, 2007 at 11:26 am
I’m with Darren! I saw Best Years of Our Lives recently and I was pleasantly surprised by how well it stood up. It had a a generosity, a socially conscious vision, and a clear-eyed realism that surprised and moved me. I like the way, for example, that the Teresa Wright character remains totally sympathetic even when, shockingly (shocking in the context of this movie, at least) she comes right out and says she intends to break up the marriage of the man she loves. I also appreciated the way the film deals with Fredric March’s alcoholism. It’s there, it’s painful, but it doesn’t get any better — there’s no treacly, comforting “recovery” arc for his character.
Robert, I think you should give this one another look.
I am also a fan of Roman Holiday, The Heiress, Wuthering Heights, the Wyler/Bette Davis films (Jezebel, The Letter, and The Little Foxes) and, to a lesser extent, Funny Girl.
The auteurists tended to scorn Wyler. His style was unobtrusive. He was never a specialist in the B pictures that the auteurists love to fetishize, and certainly he did his fair share of “prestige” pictures that Hollywood loves to congratulate itself for but were in fact rather ghastly (Mrs. Miniver and Ben-Hur being the two worst offenders in this category).
But he was a careful, subtle craftsman and the best of his films remain remarkably compelling. He was also an uncommonly gifted director of actors. Laurence Olivier credited Wyler as the director who taught him to act for the camera (in Wuthering Heights). In addition to directing the starmaking performances of Frances Farmer in Come and Get It, Audrey Hepburn in Roman Holiday and Barbra Streisand in Funny Girl, he also pulled career-best performances out of Barrymore (in Counsellor at Law), Olivia DeHavilland (The Heiress), and Bette Davis (in the three films they did together, Jezebel, The Letter, and The Little Foxes).
Perhaps most notable of all were those collaborations with Bette Davis, which still stands out as one of the landmark actor/director pairings. Davis’ performances in those remain among the most indelible of the classic Hollywood era.
January 9th, 2007 at 5:36 pm
Thanks, Darren and Kathy, for your thoughtful chiding. I’ve told a few friends that I’m convinced I’d get more comments on the blog if I started making outrageous or patently ludicrous statements. I guess I’m right.
I know I need to see Best Years of Our Lives again. I saw it at least 8-9 years ago, and I suspect I’d appreciate it more now. What I do remember bothering me about it, though, was that it felt like a bloated message movie. That Wyler knew he was saying something “important” and he was going to use his three-hour running time to make sure we didn’t miss it. I remember many of the good bits Kathy mentions, but I also remember growing increasingly frustrated. I’m not sure that feeling will change on second viewing, but I’ll give it a chance when it shows up at one of the Chicago rep theaters.
On the other hand, no one will convince me to see Roman Holiday again, no matter how much I love Audrey Hepburn (which is a lot). And that’s because it stars the great stiff himself, Gregory Peck. Rarely has a casting choice ruined a movie so. I’m also not fond of all the location sequences, which fairly scream out, “Look, we’re actually shooting in Rome!!” Bleah.
But I’ll definitely keep an eye out for the Wylers you guys recommended. I haven’t written him off yet. Though glancing at the Andrew Sarris book I got for Christmas, he describes Wyler’s career as “inflating without expanding.” Hmmm, I like that.
Neil, there was a program of Gehr’s work in Chicago this fall, but my busy schedule got in the way. I sure was kicking myself, though. On the plus side, I just found out Michael Snow will be in town in February to introduce four of his works, including Wavelength. I think I’ll have to see that again.
January 10th, 2007 at 11:16 am
Color me super-jealous. Will Snow be showing that shortened, altered version (WVLNT) along with it?
January 10th, 2007 at 11:20 am
Oh, and I can go either way when it comes to rewatching The Best Years Of Our Lives. I remember liking it–particularly the acting–the first time I watched it, but maybe not enough to do anything about it. But Roman Holiday simply must be ignored. I think that’s the only of the seven (?) Audrey Hepburn movies I’ve seen that I wouldn’t watch again.
January 10th, 2007 at 11:33 am
I saw 34 of the 35 Naruse films that were shown at Film Forum here in NYC last fall.
Thirty-four films in three or four weeks, and I was sorry to see the series end. And I’m not the only one who felt that way.
He’s a master. An absolute master. Every bit the equal of Ozu.
January 10th, 2007 at 7:39 pm
I think Wong Kar Wai paid homage to Naruse’s masterpiece with Maggie Cheung going up and down the steps “In the Mood for Love”.
Btw, the actress who appears a lot in Naruse’s film is Hideko Takamine. Keiko Yashiro is the name of character she portrayed in “Woman Ascending the Stairs”. H.Takamine was a major Japanese actress who appeared in many other great films, Twenty-four eyes and Floating Clouds to name a few.
http://www.kinema.uwaterloo.ca/hfxgp941.htm
http://humorlessfeminist.blogspot.com/2006/05/hideko-takamine_09.html
January 11th, 2007 at 10:03 am
Vitro Nasu, thanks for catching my error on Woman. I had mis-read my notes. And, yes, I hadn’t thought of the connection with In the Mood for Love, but the parallels are clear.
Brett, I only ended up seeing six or seven of the Naruses, but I didn’t find them as consistently great as I found the Ozus. Woman Ascending the Stairs is a masterpiece, obviously, but I didn’t connect as well with some of the others I saw. Maybe I picked the wrong ones to see, maybe I wasn’t ready for Naruse’s style.
January 11th, 2007 at 1:20 pm
Hideko Takamine was definitely well served by Naruse, but so were Setsuko Hara, Kinuyo Tanaka, Kyôko Kagawa, and other wonderful actresses.
His pictures are dominated by memorable performances by female performers.
January 11th, 2007 at 2:21 pm
Excellent choices all (except for Hud, imho). The Borzage and Mizoguchi films were among the highlights of my year too, along with Rossellini and Rivette retrospectives. The only one I haven’t seen is Ernie Gehr’s Side/Walk/Shuttle, which I very much look forward to seeing, especially as I’m a nostalgic former San Francisco resident.
I regrettably missed most of the Naruse films at Film Forum and am trying to catch up whenever possible. Luckily, Criterion is releasing “When a Woman Ascends the Stairs” shortly on DVD. Also thought I’d mention a great website (called to my attention by Jonathan Rosenbaum), www.ubu.com/film/ which offers free downloads of numerous avant-garde films, including a couple of Gehr’s.